TWiki
>
DICE Web
>
ResearchAndTeachingUnit
>
VMCloudSurvey
(15 Dec 2014,
IainRae
)
(raw view)
E
dit
A
ttach
---+ VM/Cloud survey This is the final report for DevProj:256 ---+ Description This project conducted a survey covering a number of subjects mostly relating to Virtualisation and cloud services. The survey specifically looked into * Current use of virtualisation within Informatics. * The viability of KVM type services * Use of cloud based data storage * Use of various SAAS/PAAS platforms * The awareness of legal implications of using the above services. The survey was implemented in house using [[https://webmark.inf.ed.ac.uk/][webmark ]] and the survey report and supporting (anonymises) information can be found in /afs/inf.ed.ac.uk/group/rat-unit/projects/devproj-256 The original survey returns can be found in the [[https://webmark.inf.ed.ac.uk/group/cloudsurvey][cloud survey]] section of webmark. ---++ Survey software A number of survey websites were looked at before we eventually chose webmark, including Isurvey, google surveys, surveymonkey and free survey. In the end we went with webmark partly because of data storage issues and partly because webmark was more flexible. In particular we didn't want to generate a very long survey with multiple pages that would take ages to complete. ---++ General survey design The survey was designed to try to obtain the maximum amount of information from the minimum of input, by using default values and allowing sensible multiple responses. Having a large number of comments fields hopefully meant that if we were providing completely the wrong answers people could tick "other" and explain what they were doing. Even a complete null response would generate meaningful information although we didn't get any of those ---++ Target audience The survey was targeted at all staff and research students in order to cover people in the school who: * Specify services for teaching and reserach. * Are most likely to handle sensitive data * Are most likely to be responsible for I.P. In general we got a reasonable response although the return from admin staff was dissapointing ---++ Time taken Amount: 5 weeks Some of this included learning to use webmark (probably 3-4 days) and there was a further 3-4 days spend playing with various bits of software in order to decide how to generate the graphs for the report. ---++ Conclusions Webmark is fairly good at generating this kind of survey, the only real let down was that it wasn't possible to generate graphs straight from the returns but this would have been beyond the scope of the software as originally specced so it's an unreasonable request. oocalc is useful for quickly throwing together results from csv files but rapidly becomes unmanagable as the complexity of the data and the questions you would like to ask of it increases. generating results of conditional queries involving multiple responses (i.e. queries along the lines of "Of the people who are currently using VMs how many are interested in a KVM service and how many of them would be willing to pay") rapidly becomes unmanagable and fraught with the possibility of error. In retrospect dumping the results into a database and using python or R would have been a better approach, albeit with a higher learning curve. We should have had some of the anaysis software in place during the trial because we missed out on some information relating to multiple questions because people responded in ways we didn't quite expect. More by luck than judgement we seemed to hit a sweet spot at the time we sent the survey out (8.30), most of the responses came back fairly quickly and we seem to have caught people when they were responsive before they'd settled down to work for the day. -- Main.IainRae - 04 Aug 2014 * [[%ATTACHURL%/surveyreport2.pdf][surveyreport2.pdf]]: Formal survey Report * The supporting files are in AFS at [[file:///afs/inf.ed.ac.uk/group/rat-unit/projects/vm_cloud_survey][/afs/inf.ed.ac.uk/group/rat-unit/projects/vm_cloud_survey]]
Attachments
Attachments
Topic attachments
I
Attachment
Action
Size
Date
Who
Comment
pdf
surveyreport2.pdf
manage
154.0 K
15 Dec 2014 - 14:13
IainRae
Formal survey Report
E
dit
|
A
ttach
|
P
rint version
|
H
istory
: r6
<
r5
<
r4
<
r3
<
r2
|
B
acklinks
|
V
iew topic
|
Ra
w
edit
|
M
ore topic actions
Topic revision: r6 - 15 Dec 2014 - 14:13:19 -
IainRae
DICE
DICE Web
DICE Wiki Home
Changes
Index
Search
Meetings
CEG
Operational
Computing Projects
Technical Discussion
Units
Infrastructure
Managed Platform
Research & Teaching
Services
User Support
Other
Service Catalogue
Platform upgrades
Procurement
Historical interest
Emergencies
Critical shutdown
Where's my software?
Pandemic planning
This is
WebLeftBar
Copyright © by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki?
Send feedback
This Wiki uses
Cookies